Butterfield Lake

About Butterfield Lake

Time spent on Butterfield Lake in Watonwan County, Minnesota, brings a quiet, intimate connection with nature. This modest-sized lake spans 54 acres, offering a shallow water experience with a maximum depth around 10 feet. Its calm waters provide a peaceful retreat near the towns of Butterfield, Mountain Lake, and St. James. The lake's setting is complemented by the nearby Kilen Woods State Park, adding a touch of protected natural landscape to the surroundings. The shallow depth encourages easy access and interaction with the lake’s aquatic environment, making it a simple yet distinct destination for those seeking a low-key outdoor escape.

Surface area

54 acres

Maximum depth

10 feet

Lake-Link Score

22.9

Member rating

1.0 (1)

Fish species

Black Bullhead, Black Crappie, Bluegill, Carp, Largemouth Bass, Northern Pike, Pumpkinseed, Yellow Perch

Fishing Butterfield Lake

Quality fishing at Butterfield Lake revolves around a mix of species that thrive in its shallow waters. Anglers may encounter Black Bullhead, Black Crappie, Bluegill, Carp, Largemouth Bass, Northern Pike, Pumpkinseed, and Yellow Perch. Although the lake supports a variety of fish, the overall fishing experience can be challenging due to the dominance of smaller species. The diversity offers some appeal for those looking to catch different types of fish, but the shallow, warm water conditions tend to favor certain species over others, influencing the overall quality and success of fishing outings here.

Ice fishing

Ice fishing on Butterfield Lake provides a seasonal opportunity to enjoy the frozen landscape of southern Minnesota. The lake’s shallow nature means anglers can experience a close connection to the ice and water beneath, making winter fishing a distinct part of the lake’s year-round character. This seasonal activity invites those who appreciate quiet, focused time outdoors during colder months.