Tap for sound
Head For The Mountains

Butternut Lake

Forest County, Wisconsin
1,246 acres Max depth 42 ft 9 angler reviews
Northern Pike Panfish Smallmouth Bass Walleye
67 Lake-Link ScoreTM

About Butternut Lake

Butternut Lake in Forest County, Wisconsin, invites visitors to enjoy its spacious waters throughout the year. Covering over 1200 acres, this lake offers a sizable playground for outdoor enthusiasts. Its moderate depth of 42 feet creates a versatile environment that supports a variety of aquatic life and recreational opportunities. The lake's clear blue waters are a standout feature, often allowing visibility down to 12 feet or more. Surrounding Butternut Lake is the Northern Highland American Legion State Forest, adding a natural backdrop that enhances the area's appeal. While there are no nearby towns, the lake's setting provides a peaceful retreat for those seeking a quiet experience in Wisconsin's northwoods. Access points are limited, with one main boat ramp reachable by a dirt road, emphasizing a rustic and less crowded atmosphere.

Surface area
1,246 acres
Maximum depth
42 feet
Lake-Link Score
67.2
Member rating
4.2 (9)

Fish species

Northern Pike, Panfish, Smallmouth Bass, Walleye

Fishing Butternut Lake

Fishing on Butternut Lake brings a rewarding experience for anglers who appreciate a mix of species and quality catches. The lake supports a strong population of smallmouth bass, known for both numbers and trophy potential, making it a favored spot for bass enthusiasts. Walleye and northern pike also provide excellent opportunities, especially in the deeper holes scattered across the lake. Panfish are present as well, although some reports suggest their numbers have declined compared to past decades. Overall, Butternut Lake offers a balanced fishing experience with species diversity that keeps each outing engaging and fruitful.

Ice fishing

Ice fishing on Butternut Lake offers a unique seasonal experience where anglers can enjoy the quiet and stillness of winter. The lake's moderate depth supports a variety of fish species beneath the ice, making it a worthwhile destination for those who embrace cold-weather fishing adventures. This seasonal activity provides a different perspective on the lake's natural beauty and fishing potential.

Butternut Lake map

Explore the lake and surrounding area.

Open full map

Fishing conditions

Sun and moon information for planning time on the water.

Sunrise and sunset

Loading sun times…

Current moon phase

Loading moon information…

Plan a trip to Butternut Lake

Find guides, lodging, and RV rentals near your destination.

Fishing guides

Find experienced guides serving the surrounding area.

Find a guide

Places to stay

Search hotels, resorts, and vacation rentals near the lake.

Find lodging

Lake information is provided for planning and recreational use. Conditions, depths, access information, and regulations may change. Always follow posted notices and local regulations.

Menu