Black Otter Lake (Hortonville)

About Black Otter Lake (Hortonville)

Black Otter Lake in Outagamie County, Wisconsin, is a modestly sized lake covering just over 76 acres. Its shallow waters, reaching a maximum depth of only 9 feet, create a rich environment full of aquatic vegetation. The lake's setting near Hortonville and other small towns adds a quiet, local charm to the fishing experience. The lake's dense weed beds shape much of its character, providing habitat for various species and making it a unique spot for anglers who appreciate a more natural, less disturbed fishing environment. Nearby High Cliff State Park adds a scenic backdrop to this peaceful Wisconsin waterbody.

Surface area

77 acres

Maximum depth

9 feet

Lake-Link Score

80.9

Member rating

4.4 (30)

Fish species

Largemouth Bass, Northern Pike, Panfish

Fishing Black Otter Lake (Hortonville)

Fishing at Black Otter Lake offers a variety of opportunities, especially for anglers targeting largemouth bass, northern pike, and panfish. The shallow, weed-filled waters create a lively habitat where panfish like bluegills and perch thrive, making it a favorite for those seeking steady action. Bass and northern pike are also present, with some anglers reporting catches of respectable size. The dense vegetation can challenge certain fishing methods but supports a solid fish population that rewards persistence and local knowledge.

Ice fishing

Winter transforms Black Otter Lake into a lively ice fishing destination. Anglers enjoy targeting a mix of species through the ice, with panfish and northern pike providing consistent action. The lake's shallow depth allows for accessible ice fishing spots, making it a popular choice for those looking to spend cold days outdoors in Wisconsin.