Plymouth Mill Pond

About Plymouth Mill Pond

In Sheboygan County, Wisconsin, Plymouth Mill Pond offers a modest but inviting fishing spot surrounded by the towns of Plymouth, Glenbeulah, and Waldo. This shallow lake spans about 36 acres with a maximum depth around six feet, making it accessible and productive for anglers who appreciate smaller, intimate waters. The pond's setting is complemented by nearby natural areas like Kohler-Andrae State Park and Harrington Beach State Park, which add to the regional outdoor experience. The pond's size and depth create a unique environment where shallow water species thrive, and the surrounding communities provide convenient access for visitors. Its location in Wisconsin's varied landscape makes it a quiet retreat for those seeking a day on the water without the bustle of larger lakes.

Surface area

36 acres

Maximum depth

6 feet

Lake-Link Score

55.0

Member rating

2.9 (9)

Fish species

Bluegill, Largemouth Bass, Northern Pike

Fishing Plymouth Mill Pond

Quality fishing at Plymouth Mill Pond centers on a few key species that do well in its shallow, warm waters. Anglers often find bluegill and largemouth bass, which are common in smaller Midwestern lakes and provide steady action. Northern pike also inhabit the pond, offering chances for trophy catches, especially in spring and early summer when water temperatures are cooler. The mix of species here suits anglers looking for a variety of freshwater fish in a compact setting. While the pond doesn't reach great depths, its habitat supports a range of fish that respond well to typical freshwater fishing methods, making it a worthwhile stop for local and visiting anglers alike.

Ice fishing

Ice fishing is a seasonal highlight at Plymouth Mill Pond, with the lake freezing over during Wisconsin's cold months. This shallow water body offers anglers a chance to pursue species like northern pike and bluegill through the ice, providing a different yet rewarding fishing experience when winter settles in the region.